Why Trumps Closing Argument on Coronavirus Clashes with Science and Voters – The New York Times

As an immense new surge in coronavirus cases sweeps the country, President Trump is closing his re-election campaign by pleading with voters to ignore the evidence of a calamity unfolding before their eyes and trust his word that the disease is already disappearing as a threat to their personal health and economic well being.

The president has continued to declare before large and largely maskless crowds that the virus is vanishing, even as case counts soar, fatalities climb, the stock market dips and a fresh outbreak grips the staff of Vice President Mike Pence. Hopping from one state to the next, he has made a personal mantra out of declaring that the country is rounding the corner.

Mr. Trump has attacked Democratic governors and other local officials for keeping public-health restrictions in place, denouncing them as needless restraints on the economy. And venting self-pity, the president has been describing the pandemic as a political hindrance inflicted on him by a familiar adversary.

With the fake news, everything is Covid, Covid, Covid, Covid, Mr. Trump complained at a rally in Omaha on Tuesday, chiding the news media and pointing to his own recovery from the illness to downplay its gravity: I had it. Here I am, right?

Earlier the same day, Mr. Trump ridiculed the notion that the virus was spreading rapidly again, falsely telling a crowd in Lansing, Mich., that the reported spike in cases was merely a reflection of increased testing. The 74-year-old president pointed to his teenage son, who was diagnosed with the virus earlier this month, to suggest that many of those cases were of only trivial concern.

Do you ever notice, they dont use the word death, they use the word cases? Mr. Trump said. Like, Barron Trump is a case. He has sniffles, he was sniffling. One Kleenex, thats all he needed, and he was better. But hes a case.

As a political matter, the presidents approach amounts to an Obi Wan-like attempt to wave his hand before the electorate and tell voters that they are not experiencing a pandemic that is tearing through their neighborhoods and filling hospitals. His determination to brush aside the ongoing crisis as a campaign issue has become the defining choice of his bid for a second term and the core of his message throughout the campaigns endgame.

There is considerable evidence it is not working. The stock market, long the focal point of Mr. Trumps cheerleading efforts, plunged by more than 900 points on Wednesday, suffering its worst drop in months as investors grappled with the mounting disruptions wrought by the pandemic. Polling and interviews with voters show that most are not inclined to trust Mr. Trumps sunny forecast.

Mr. Trumps description of the disease is ungrounded in fact, and his theory of countering it has clashed with the preferences of medical officials at every level of government. The country has reported more than 8.8 million cases of the coronavirus, including a 39 percent increase in new cases over the last 14 days. More than 227,000 Americans have perished from the disease.

In Bullhead City, Ariz., on Wednesday, Mr. Trump promised voters that a vaccine would be available momentarily, though scientists and pharmaceutical companies say no such breakthrough is assured. Using a phrase that has become a refrain for him at rallies, he insisted the country was rounding the turn on the virus.

Keep up with Election 2020

In the states Mr. Trump is visiting, his presence can stir as much anxiety as excitement, as voters fear the impact of large public gatherings.

Allison Drennan, an independent voter from Gastonia, N.C., said she was voting for Joseph R. Biden Jr., the Democratic nominee, in part because of Mr. Trumps mishandling of the coronavirus. Last week, she was dismayed to see that Mr. Trump was holding a rally in her area, because it had the potential to help spread the disease.

I think its a huge mistake, Ms. Drennan, 29, said of the rally, citing specific details about the local impact of the pandemic. We have 77 people in our hospitals in Gastonia with Covid already. Ive decided Im going to self-isolate to the extent that I can for the next two weeks.

The numbers in North Carolina support her inclination toward caution. While the state has managed to keep the disease more contained than some other large states, its average daily case count has risen by 13 percent over the last two weeks. There have been more than 266,000 cases in the state, with a death toll of 4,269 as of Wednesday afternoon.

Ashley Narten, 37, of Minocqua, Wis., lost her job as a waitress for five months this year when her restaurant cut back shifts. When she finally went back to work in September, she got the virus herself.

After completing quarantine, she took her young sons to see her cast a ballot for Mr. Biden. She said she was deeply pessimistic about the trajectory of the pandemic.

I just dont know how we can live and have an economy while its going around, she said.

In Wisconsin, which on Tuesday reported record totals for new cases and deaths, a Marquette University Law School poll published Wednesday showed that 58 percent of voters there disapproved of the presidents handling of the pandemic. Mr. Biden was leading Mr. Trump in the crucial state by five percentage points.

Like much else about Mr. Trumps mode of leadership, his view of the pandemic has found an enthusiastic audience from a minority of the country. A national poll published recently by The Times found that nearly two in five voters agreed with Mr. Trump that the worst of the crisis was over. The presidents push to fully reopen the economy is not without appeal, at least to the voters who already support him, and they have remained loyal through various personal and political scandals, policy breakdowns and an impeachment trial.

Oct. 29, 2020, 7:49 p.m. ET

But polls show that far more Americans are rejecting the Trump approach. In the same Times survey, most voters said that the worst of the pandemic was still ahead, including half of independent voters and a fifth of Republicans. By a 12-point margin, voters said they preferred Mr. Biden to lead the response to the pandemic rather than Mr. Trump. And 59 percent of voters said they favored a national mask mandate, including majorities of Democratic and independent voters, and three in 10 Republicans.

Felix Vristow, 40, of Philadelphia, said he believed Mr. Trump had been dishonest about the disease.

Our leader lied to us, in my eyes, Mr. Vristow said, adding, We experienced way too many deaths, and it could have been prevented if the situation was addressed earlier or more honestly.

Mr. Biden has spent the general election campaign offering himself to those voters as a responsible alternative. Seeking both to model good behavior and to protect his own health, Mr. Biden, 77, has kept a strictly limited campaign schedule, holding no large rallies and traveling far less frequently than a typical presidential nominee. On Wednesday, rather than appearing in a swing state, he made remarks from his home state, Delaware, rebuking what he called Mr. Trumps declaration of surrender to the virus.

Just as notably, some senior federal officials have also pushed back in recent days against the presidents rhetoric about the coronavirus and his false claims that case counts are going up only because testing has increased. Mr. Trump has often spoken about testing as a kind of public-relations problem, shifting line graphs that track the virus in an unhelpful direction for him.

In a television interview Wednesday, Adm. Brett Giroir, the administrations testing czar, rebutted Mr. Trumps characterization of the pandemic without chiding the president by name. The rising case count, he said, was not just a function of testing.

Yes, were getting more cases identified, but the cases are actually going up, Admiral Giroir said, urging Americans to wear masks and avoid clustering indoors.

In a different kind of departure from Mr. Trumps upbeat line, Mark Meadows, the White House chief of staff, acknowledged last weekend on television that the administration was not going to control the pandemic a remark Mr. Biden brandished as confirmation that Mr. Trump was capitulating.

Still, Mr. Trump has continued to pack airplane hangars and outdoor spaces with sympathetic fans who have embraced his account of a country quickly returning to normalcy. In Wisconsin, where new cases have skyrocketed by 46 percent in the last two weeks, Mike Mitchell, a retail manager who backs Mr. Trump, blamed out-of-town visitors for the uptick in his area.

We saw personally what happened here when things reopened for tourism the cases skyrocketed, said Mr. Mitchell, faulting interlopers from Milwaukee and Chicago rather than Mr. Trump.

In Florida, where residents spent the summer battling a wave of infections, at least some Trump admirers were still willing to give the president the benefit of the doubt on the virus. One of them is John DAmato, a Republican retiree who moved to Southwest Florida from Minnesota.

I may not agree with the way he tweets and everything else, but hes turned this country around, and hell do it again, said Mr. DAmato, 71, who wore a mask to vote near downtown Fort Myers last week.

For most voters, however, Mr. Trumps insistence that happy days are almost here again has fallen flat.

As Ken Hueftle waited in line to vote outside Philadelphias City Hall, he described an up-close experience of the pandemic that could not have diverged more starkly from Mr. Trumps prognosis. Mr. Hueftle, a 30-year-old physician assistant, said he had seen from his work at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital that the governments response to the virus had been awful.

Mr. Hueftle said he was voting accordingly.

At this point, theres no choice, he said. You have to vote. Its life or death.

Reporting was contributed by Patricia Mazzei from Fort Myers, Fla.; Nick Corasaniti from Philadelphia; Annie Karni from Gastonia, N.C.; and Reid J. Epstein from Minocqua, Wis.

Read this article:

Why Trumps Closing Argument on Coronavirus Clashes with Science and Voters - The New York Times